112 Comments
User's avatar
Sophie Lalani's avatar

FWIW: Another paid sub from the start here! Haley’s writing has truly changed my life. So much of her insight bounces around in my head each and every day. Her work has pushed my thinking in transformative, wonderful ways. She’s a thought-provoking, wise, and charming writer and I can’t recommend a paid subscription enough. ❤️

Expand full comment
Haley Nahman's avatar

🥲

Expand full comment
Shira's avatar

Same. Her writing has changed the way I think about my own life. Huge.

Expand full comment
Giorgia's avatar

Completely agree! What a gift

Expand full comment
Dylan's avatar

I look forward to a Sunday morning Maybe Baby read in bed every single week. The amount of times someone has asked “who are you texting??” But it’s just me leaving a long ass comment because I’ve just read something that Really Makes You Think - definitely more than a few times. One of my favorite slices of the internet since March 2020 for so many reasons but especially because it has remained immune to so much of the bad influencer marketing tone that has infiltrated literally everything. $6 a month is nothing to lose and everything to gain! Happy Birthday Maybe Baby! ❣️

Expand full comment
cjl's avatar

Yes! A sunday morning staple lol

Expand full comment
Katie's avatar

I think there’s probably a portion of your existing paid subscriber population that would happily pay more (evidence of 1 person here, others feel free to chime in…). Netflix charges me $19 a month for content that I access way less (and value way less!!) than yours. Not sure if there’s a way around the paid/unpaid duality—like a tip jar of sorts. Ex. if there was an option for (1) subscription, plus (2) optional monthly contribution to Sunny college fund, I’d click that button in a heartbeat.

Expand full comment
Haley Nahman's avatar

This is so sweet. You already do enough!!

Expand full comment
L_S's avatar

I agree! I was recently thinking of writing to you and suggesting this Haley.

Expand full comment
L_S's avatar

Ooh just learned this is actually an option thanks to another commenter. Upgraded! ✌🏼✔️

Expand full comment
Harling Ross Anton's avatar

HAPPY FIVE YEARS I still remember when you texted me the newsletter name idea Gut Flora to which I think I replied something along the lines of "let's try and think of something less intestinal"

love ya!!!!

Expand full comment
Haley Nahman's avatar

LOL Harls

Expand full comment
Celeste's avatar

I was just so scared that this was an announcement that Maybe Baby was ending! Paid reader since day 1 and can’t tell you how much joy and fodder your writing has brought me. And how many great conversations I’ve had with friends, my mom, my partner after reading your essays. Also can you please tell us where exactly to go dancing in New York? ❤️

Expand full comment
Sophie Lalani's avatar

Omg Maybe Baby ending would cause a level of devastation I simply cannot handle

Expand full comment
cjl's avatar

Happy five years Haley!! not to be dramatic, but your writing has changed my life- your essay on mediocrity (#161 unhappy medium) helped me get the courage to end my six-year relationship.

Almost two years later, I've never been happier (even whilst dealing w/ the unhinged deli guy situation of course). Yay

Expand full comment
Haley Nahman's avatar

CJL 😭 I'm so moved by this, thank you. And to think you changed my life right back with that amazing dear danny question

Expand full comment
Hannah's avatar

Proud paid subscriber since day one :-) Happy 5th anniversary! To many more 🥂

Expand full comment
MM's avatar

same!! the best money spent, happy birthday maybe baby!!

Expand full comment
Paige Taylor's avatar

Me, a paid subscriber for years, locked in reading this pitch and agreeing wholeheartedly. Soooo worth the $5/month

Expand full comment
Haley Nahman's avatar

Hahahaha ❤️

Expand full comment
Alicia's avatar

real

Expand full comment
Ariane Eagan's avatar

This little nudge was all I needed to re-subscribe as paid. I am constantly trying to trim down what I pay for as a subscription service because there are just SO MANY things that pile up, but I must have been on a manic (delusional!) purge when I let this one go. Thanks Haley, can't wait to keep following along. Also, pls truly feel free to hunt me down if I once again try to make Maybe Baby shoulder the blame for my excessive subscriptions and retail therapy habits. 🫶🏼

Expand full comment
Haley Nahman's avatar

Welcome back queen!!

Expand full comment
Rae's avatar

Chiming in with more encouragement to upgrade to paid! This is the only newsletter I always open. The recs are so thoughtful. I’m always introduced to new ideas, new sources, and sweet glimpses of Haley’s week — the list is perfectly curated, and I especially appreciate it’s focused on genuine personal recommendations, not consumerism for its own sake. Dear Danny alone is worth the price of admission and I’d devour it if it were three times as long. I adore the banter and the advice is wise, thoughtful, and unexpected. Keep being the best, Haley! Thanks for all you give in your work.

Expand full comment
Brittany Felton's avatar

I look forward to every single newsletter that hits my inbox. Love your writing soooo much and while I cycle in paid subs for other newsletters, yours has always been a constant. Thanks for all you do!!! Cheers to expansion!!

Expand full comment
Josie's avatar

a weekly invitation to think critically and generously about my own life since day one —

highlights:

• the decoding the love bomber dear danny ep

• ‘my gods’ essay

• whichever essay was published on 3/4/2024 (per my screenshots folder) on gut feelings, etc.

Expand full comment
Tanya Kertsman's avatar

Paid subscriber since the beginning. :) I look forward to reading it every week!

Expand full comment
Amanda's avatar

Happy five years, Haley! Very very grateful for this slice of the internet that you’ve carved out 💛

Expand full comment
Ramey Dallimonti's avatar

My partner and I look forward to Maybe Baby every week and 35% of the time one of us reads it to the other. Haley has such a unique voice and each of her three weekly publications are either thought provoking, informative or fun - most often all 3. This is the only Substack I pay for and the only one I really care to :)

Expand full comment
Haley Nahman's avatar

😭

Expand full comment
Iris (they/them)'s avatar

so many aspects of Maybe Baby paid sub are top-notch quality and I genuinely anticipate and seek out Maybe Baby editions in my inbox / eps in my podcast feed on specific days of the week or times of the month. (like I’ll think to myself oooh, it’s Mar 15, Dear Danny will be out any day now 👁️👄👁️)

also YES to the marvelous comments section. if the business people at Substack had a way to analyze Maybe Baby scroll-through-comments rates they’d surely try to make a webinar out of the phenomenon

Expand full comment
Haley Nahman's avatar

Omg the mysterious dear danny drop date hahaha

Hell yeah to the comments

Expand full comment
Hannah's avatar

A couple of people have said to me recently “you always read such interesting articles” and both times it’s been because I’ve been talking about links that I have found in your newsletter. Congratulations on five years, and thank you for your work!

Expand full comment
Haley Nahman's avatar

Yayy thank you hannah!!

Expand full comment